Main Navigation:

Appendix 8 HMA v McKie: Witnesses And Transcripts

Witnesses

The list of witnesses in table A5 with the date(s) on which they gave evidence is taken from Mr Carle's report.¹

Table A5

Date	Name	Description
Wed 21 April	DC Douglas Wallace	Police
Thurs 22 April	Mr Michael Moffat	SOCO
Thurs 22 April	CI Stephen Heath DCI Alexander McAllister CI James Thomson DS Janet Lunardi DC James Kirkland PC Allan Stevens	Police " " " " "
Fri 23 April	Juror ill - no sitting
Tues 27 April	DS William Shields Insp Robert Pollock DS Allister Crawford DC Joseph Quay PC Graeme McIntyre Sgt Derek Thomson PC Archibald McKinlay CI Ian Hogg PC William Jamieson PC Gary Hutchison	Police " " " " " " " Police log-keeper "
Wed 28 April	PC David Thurley	SOCO
Wed 28 April	Alan Dewar	Advocate Depute in trial HMA v Asbury
Thurs 29 April	PC Anne Halliday PC Lisa Dunlop DC James Kerr PC Bryan McGeoch PC Mark Lees	Police log-keeper " Police (Production Officer) Police log-keeper "
Thurs 29 April	Mr Stuart Wilson	SOCO
Fri 30 April	Mr Stuart Wilson Mr Graham Hunter	SOCO "
	Miss Isobel Davies	Crown Office
	DS Steven Wilson PC Graham Hope PC Jennifer Ellis PC Elaine Fraser PC Kevin Maguire PC Margaret Baird PC Robert Johnstone PC Gillian Stirling PC Gary Toye PC Alan Mack PC Lynne Nicol PC Julie O'Neill PC Greg Dinnie PC Scott Telford	Police " Police log-keeper " " Police log-keeper " " " " " " " "
Mon 3 May	Public Holiday
Tues 4 May	PC Gary Mitchell PC Gary Rowe PC Elizabeth Sleight PC Henry McKissock PC George Whiteside PC Anthony Parker PC Eric Garrick PC Ronald Hamilton PC Jan Ziolo PC Edward Vallance PC Wilson Nisbet DC Mark Swan	Police log-keeper " " " " " " " " " " Police
	Mr David Ferguson	SOCO
	Mr Keith Eynon	Forensic Scientist
	PC Patricia Faulds DS Rosalind Morris	Police "
	Mr Charles Stewart	Fingerprint Officer
Wed 5 May	Mr Charles Stewart	Fingerprint Officer
Thurs 6 May	Mr Charles Stewart	Fingerprint Officer
	Mr Terence Kent	Home Office
	PC James Brand	Police log-keeper
	Ms Fiona McBride	Fingerprint Officer
Fri 7 May	Mr Hugh MacPherson	Fingerprint Officer
Fri 7 May Defence	Mr John Wheeler	Special Constable (retired) log-keeper
	PC Scott Grant	Police
Mon 10 May	No sitting
Tues 11 May	Ms Shirley McKie
Tues 11 May	Mr Pat Wertheim	Fingerprint Consultant
Wed 12 May	Mr Pat Wertheim
Thurs 13 May	Mr David Grieve	Latent print trainer co-ordinator
Thurs 13 May	Mr Murphy and Mr Findlay's speeches to the jury
Fri 14 May	Lord Johnston's charge to the jury
	Verdict

Transcripts
Where a transcript of all or part of the evidence of these witnesses at the trial is available this is listed in table A6.

Table A6

Date	Reference	Witness	Stage	Pages on pdf	CO_0214 section
Tues 4 May	SG_0525	Mr Stewart	examination in chief	3-49	67-73.2
Wed 5 May	SG_0526	Mr Stewart	examination in chief cross-examination	3-107 107-272	67-71.4 71.5-71.8
Thurs 6 May	SG_0527	Mr Stewart	cross-examination re-examination	3-71 71-84	72-72.6 72.7-73.2
Thurs 6 May	SG_0528	Ms McBride	examination in chief cross-examination re-examination	4-27 27-42 42-46	76-76.7 76.8-76.12 76.13-76.16
Fri 7 May	SG_0529	Mr MacPherson	examination in chief cross-examination re-examination	3-48 48-61 61-65	77-77.9 77.10-77.12 77.13-77.15
Tues 11 May	SG_0531	Ms McKie	examination in chief cross-examination re-examination	3-51 5-119 119-123	85-85.20 86-86.14 86.15-86.16
Tues 11 May	SG_0531	Mr Wertheim	examination in chief	123-181	87-87.12
Wed 12 May	CO_2746	Mr Wertheim	examination in chief cross-examination re-examination	3-51 5-166 166-169	88-88.11 89-89.21 89.22-89.23
Thurs 13 May	SG_0532	Mr Grieve	examination in chief cross-examination re-examination	3-27 27-57 57-60	90-90.6 90.7-90.14 90.15
Fri 14 May	CO_1465	Lord Johnston's charge to the jury and verdict			93-93.7

Footnotes

1. CO_0214